A leading tech entrepreneur has defended the emergency alert test sent to mobile phones against what he says is “unfair criticism”.
Millions received the alert at 3pm last Sunday (23 April) when the Government tested a system to warn people at risk from calamities such as fires, floods and terrorist attacks. An alarm sounded and the words “severe alert” flashed on screens.
But some people didn’t get the alert – including many users of the mobile network Three – while others received it twice, or earlier or later than planned, prompting widespread criticism and even ridicule in the media.
Brad Kieser, chief executive of the omni-channel communications company SMS Speedway, says that glitches are to be expected with a test of this sort –indeed the whole point is to identify problems.
Writing on the business social media platform LinkedIn, he said: “The national alerting test inevitably had failures.
“These systems are big, complicated and take time to perfect.
“Designing and coding for scale is a specialist activity. Even the most experienced IT staff working fastidiously carefully will find that their system encounters problems in the real world.
“SpaceX recently saw their magnificent Starship explode mid-air despite years of hard work, testing, debugging and review.
“A system might test perfectly in the lab but this is functional testing.”
Brad founded SMS Speedway, based in Carlisle, Cumbria, in the mid-1990s.
It operates in 124 countries offering a variety of services including SMS messaging, WhatsApp Business, password protection, anti-fraud, anti-money laundering and compliance products.
One of its newest products is the revolutionary KnowingmeID app, developed in a joint venture with the Swedish company Svipe, which allows users to prove their identity without sharing sensitive personal data.
Brad’s experience of applying cutting-edge technology to develop innovative products gives him an insight into the difficulties the alert testers face.
He added: “At SMS Speedway we have perfected our system over 25 years. It took time and a huge amount of effort to get there.
“So it is with messaging at scale. More pedestrian messaging can operate on a transactional, per message, basis.
“Messaging at scale is a different beast. The system architecture changes from the more familiar transactional design to the more esoteric data-flow designs.”
Engineers are analysing the results of the emergency alert test, which lasted for around 10 seconds on 4G and 5G devices.
Older 2G or 3G phones did not get the alert, nor did phones that were switched off or in aeroplane mode.
The Government says people can opt out of future alerts through their device settings. Those that do want them are advised to ensure their phones run the latest software – Android 11 or later or iOS 14.5 or later for Apple.

