Is positive discrimination lawful?

Caroline Rayner of Baines Wilson LLP

Positive discrimination is a type of discrimination where a person is treated more favourably than another because they have a protected characteristic, says Caroline Rayner of Baines Wilson LLP, but is it unlawful?

Positive discrimination is generally prohibited under the Equality Act 2010, unless one of the exceptions applies.  The Royal Air Force (‘RAF’) has been in the headlines this week for apparently attempting to promote women and those from ethnic minorities over their white male counterparts in order to hit their diversity targets.

It has been reported this week that the RAF made orders to prioritise women and those from ethnic minorities in allocating slots on RAF training courses over their white male counterparts.

The order was given to the Group Captain Recruitment and Selection (“Group Captain”), a senior female officer, who was based at RAF Cranwell in Lincolnshire. It is understood that her team were instructed to “course load any remaining women and EM [ethnic minorities] in those priority professions that are ready, even if the EA [enlisted aviator] candidates are not ‘first past the post’.” The RAF ordinarily uses the “first past the post” system in recruitment so that slots are given to candidates who pass the various stages of selection such as aptitude, medical and fitness tests.

The Group Captain apparently refused to allocate slots based purely on gender or ethnicity, as she believed that to do so would be unlawful and against the RAF’s own legal guidance. Whilst she agreed that it was important to ensure that they should do all they can to support that RAF’s commitment to increasing diversity, she responded that “this should be achieved through lawful and proportionate means”.

The Group Captain is said to have resigned on the same day as receiving the order, because she was not willing to carry it out or force it on her recruitment team.

A spokesperson from the RAF has disputed the allegations and said that the team was asked “pause” offering training slots to all candidates whilst they considered how they could take lawful steps including positive action to improve diversity levels.

The RAF has said that the concerns have been addressed and that it recruits people from the widest possible pool of talent and is becoming more diverse, but will not do so “at the expense of its high standards, operational effectiveness or adherence to legal obligations”.

Comment

Positive discrimination, along with most other types of discrimination, in employment is unlawful.  One of the exceptions to this is where an occupational requirement applies, i.e., where it is necessary to be of a particular sex, race, age or have any other protected characteristic due to the nature of the work.  Positive discrimination is also allowed where it is due to a person’s disability, and it may sometimes be required where there is a duty to make reasonable adjustments however employers should proceed with caution.

This story highlights the importance of ensuring any decisions around recruitment or promotion within the workplace are based on an individual’s ability to carry out the role, and are in accordance with the organisation’s equality and diversity policy and the Equality Act 2010. In this case, if the RAF has allowed its aim to meet diversity targets to take precedence over the general prohibition on positive discrimination (on the grounds of race and sex here) then this would have been unlawful.

It’s important that employers understand the difference between unlawful positive discrimination and taking lawful “positive action”.  The Equality Act allows employers to take positive action where people of a particular protected characteristic are for example disadvantaged or disproportionately under-represented in a workplace.  Employers can take certain steps to enable or encourage those people to overcome the disadvantage or to participate, without discriminating against people without that characteristic, as long as the steps taken are proportionate.

This might include e.g. providing support and mentoring, targeted advertising, making statements in recruitment advertisements that applications from the target group are welcome or targeted networking opportunities.  It is vital that those involved in recruitment are trained on their legal obligations and that a well-implemented policy is in place to minimise the risk of falling foul of the legal obligations in this context.

If you have any questions in relation to recruitment, discrimination, or any other HR queries, please contact our employment team on 01228 552600 or 01524 548494.

This alert does not provide a full statement of the law and readers are advised to take legal advice before taking any action based on the information contained herein.

Posted in Alerts, Latest News, News

Read More Articles

PREVIOUS

Leave a Reply

*

I accept the Privacy Policy