A very expensive lesson in grievances

Caroline Rayner of Baines Wilson LLP

Today we look at an unusual case which highlights the importance of keeping an open mind, free from bias, assumptions and stereotypes, during a grievance investigation and appeal, says Caroline Rayner of Baines Wilson LLP.

It also serves as a reminder that conclusions should not be formed until those investigating have spoken to all relevant parties and considered all of the relevant information.

X v (1) VolkerRail Limited (2) Z

X was employed by VolkerRail from 2019 to 2020.  She started her employment on a salary of £55,000 with a reasonable expectation that her pay would progress. During her employment, she began to form a close relationship with a married colleague (“Z”), a member of senior management, who went on to make multiple romantic advances towards her.

X and Z began communicating extensively via Teams, telephone, text messages, LinkedIn, email and face to face. The transcript of Teams messages provided to the tribunal ran to over 600 pages in a compressed format. The proportion of communication which was personal and not work-related was described as extraordinary and went beyond a good working relationship. However, X told Z that she didn’t want a romantic relationship because of her commitment to work and her culture.  In November 2019, Z repeatedly contacted X outside of working hours, e.g. asking when she would be back at the hotel where they were staying for a work trip, asking her to leave a work function with him, sending suggestive emojis and inviting her out for dinner.

Around this time, Z also became X’s line manager and the communication between them continued.  X dismissed Z’s romantic overtures with good humour and wanted to remain friends. It did not cause her to re-think whether she worked for Z or not and did not seem to distress her, as the level of contact continued.  Z supported X’s aspirations for a salary of £70,000 when she moved to his team and treated her as a “second in command”.

In January 2020, Z told X on several occasions that he “really liked” her and that he “couldn’t stop thinking about her”.  At this point X became distressed, sought advice from a friend and put her phone on “airplane” mode – however Z continued to send her messages on the subject.  She again rejected his advances.  Shortly after, Z became annoyed during discussions with X about her salary.  After the pandemic hit in March 2020, focus was lost and the salary decision making was slowed.  Z continued to show his romantic hopes through messaging.  X tried to reduce their contact which strained their working relationship, with Z becoming moody and unpleasant towards her.

X was later offered an increased salary of £60,000 by Z, although he did not make that decision.  He encouraged her to raise a grievance if she was not happy about it, due to their previous discussions on the matter and he knew she was aiming for £70,000. X decided instead that she was going to resign, citing in her resignation letter that this was due to the company’s failure to deliver on salary. X however believed that the reason she had not received her salary expectations was because she had rebuffed Z in his romantic intentions.

Discussions then took place to try and pause the resignation with a view to X staying in employment.  X was told that the offer of £60,000 remained open for acceptance which was unsatisfactory to her. On 1 July 2020, X raised harassment allegations against Z in a grievance.

Ms Diggles (HR) and Ms Kennedy heard X’s grievance.  They had decided at an early stage that the grievance was likely in bad faith.   X was not asked about key documents and people were not interviewed who should have been.  Notes taken in meetings were not complete and typed notes did not match manuscript ones.  Given the length of the allegations, the meetings were short.  X was off sick by this time.  She believed her resignation was on hold and had not been processed.  The outcome of the grievance investigation was that although there had been inappropriate behaviour by Z, it did not amount to sexual harassment.  There was no formal meeting or process against Z, until December 2020 when he accepted a final written warning instead of a formal process.  At an outcome meeting at the end of July, X was told her last day would be 20 August and her resignation was confirmed and processed.

Ms Diggles had sought to paint X in a bad light and set out why she thought X had been unreasonable in her view, but did not ask X about this in the grievance, and failed to identify any wrongdoing on the part of Z.  The grievance report distressed X when she read it, as it played down Z’s conduct.

X responded setting out the history of the resignation and said that her resignation had been withdrawn pending the resolution of the issues and remained withdrawn.  She was told that she could not withdraw her resignation without mutual agreement and that she would leave on 20 August.

X appealed against the grievance outcome but was unsuccessful and on 21 October 2020, submitted claims at the Tribunal for sex-based harassment, victimisation and sexual harassment.

Decision

The Tribunal found that Z’s conduct amounted to sexual harassment, however X was out of time to bring those claims against Z.

It was however found that, unusually, the way in which VolkerRail had handled X’s grievance and appeal was in itself discriminatory and amounted to harassment.  The tribunal found that the grievance hearers were in denial about Z’s romantic conduct towards X.  Their purpose was to show that Z was not guilty of sexual harassment by any means, whether by blaming X or comparing his behaviour to the playground.  Their conduct of the grievance process violated X’s dignity once more.  Their mental processes were influenced by stereotypes in seeking to play down male romantic endeavours.  To deny the obvious findings amounted to discrimination and harassment.  Furthermore, the refusal to allow X to withdraw her resignation as requested amounted to victimisation due to her raising allegations of discrimination.

The grievance appeal then perpetuated a stereotype of X as a “scheming femme fatale” who had sought to make money from Z’s pursuit of her and who would not have presented a grievance had her unreasonable salary demands been met.  The tribunal said that the grievance appeal was conducted with bias and a sex-related stereotype was adopted to find against X, so the grievance appeal also amounted to harassment.

X was awarded £419,352.94 at a remedy hearing, including awards for injury to feelings (£24,000 – top of the middle Vento band), general damages for psychiatric injury (£30,000 – moderately severe), past and future financial losses and interest.

Comment

This case highlights the importance of employers conducting a full and thorough grievance investigation. In doing so, employers must ensure that they do not begin to form their conclusions until they have gathered all of the available evidence and given consideration to the same.

In this case, the failure on behalf of the parties involved in hearing both the grievance and the appeal to consider the facts without bias and an open mind, resulted in them forming early conclusions as to the outcome of the grievance before the investigation had concluded. This led to an outcome being delivered which had not fully assessed the gravity of the allegations that had been raised.

It also highlights the importance of effective training, both in relation to handling grievances and equality, diversity and anti-harassment and bullying.  Had X’s claims against Z not been out of time, it is likely that awards would have been made in relation to his conduct in addition to the company in terms of how it handled the grievance and appeal.

If you have any questions in relation to grievance procedures, require assistance with employment tribunal claims or have any other HR queries, please contact our employment team on 01228 552600 or 01524 548494.

Leave a Reply

*

I accept the Privacy Policy