
WE are delighted to welcome Jamie Shail, owner of Rothay Manor in Ambleside who begins his monthly ‘View from a Lake District Hotelier’ post .
London restaurateur Jonathan Downey, owner of one of Soho’s most revered bars and eateries Milk & Honey during April began a conversation suggesting the option of a nine-month National Time Out for the hospitality sector to run from April to December. His idea being a non-government funded initiative to allow the sector some breathing space and give businesses a little leeway with regards to rent and debt payments, ultimately with the overall view of helping to save the UK hospitality industry.
This plan was later revised by Downey and a new proposal was submitted to the Treasury requesting a full year out, running from March 2020 to March 2021 whilst a business is closed and then shifting to a turnover based rent formula once it reopens.
Essentially the new proposal outlined that all hospitality tenants would be entitled to claim on the basis of government enforced closure, with physical distancing making it impossible to operate.
It also acknowledges that if a business had already partially opened, to provide a takeaway or delivery service for example, then the rent-free period would be limited to the 15 weeks of lockdown, between 25 March and 4 July.
And for businesses able to reopen from 4 July and diners return, the landlord would then decide between tenants paying either a turnover rent (e.g. 10% net turnover) or a reduced rent (e.g. 25% of the prevailing rent.)
Despite the government introducing the job retention scheme, a three-month rent forfeiture moratorium, which has now been extended to the end of September, access to business continuity loans, business rate relief and more recently a one month Eat out To Help Out scheme, and reduced levels of VAT the sector is still in dire straits.
Years of excessive rents, slim margins, and rising costs in terms of staff, produce and ancillary items is forcing many to take stock and decide if the struggle is worth continuing. Ultimately the measures the government has introduced are short term, there is still a very real need for the sector to take stock, and for landlords and creditors to work with the sector to give as many businesses as possible every chance of surviving.
During the four months of lockdown many businesses I the sector simply had no income, but have had to continue to make rent payments and in many cases in full, Inevitably this has forced many to close and others no doubt will follow suit in short order.
I believe the suggested National Time Out scheme is worth considering it not only helps the hospitality sector it would also help the landlords too, especially as many have borrowed against their value of their buildings. The scheme in essence proposes a rent-free period for time a tenant’s business was closed because of Covid-19, in most cases about four months. Then for the rest of the year, the tenant would pay 10% of their turnover as opposed to their full rent. Whilst the landlord would benefit from a debt repayment break from their bank or receive help from the Government’s £330billion Covid-19 loan guarantee scheme.
It’s imperative that something is done otherwise we will witness a raft of inevitable business closures as landlords begin eviction proceedings in October. Simply put, unless landlords, banks, the hospitality sector, and government get around the negotiating table in short order we will see hundreds of thousands of jobs simply vanish.
Businesses couldn’t meet their rent payments with little or no income and now despite slowly and tentatively reopening they are no better off. Income levels are low, especially for those in inner cities as people seek to visit the countryside and continue to work from home.
Ordinarily 120,000 people or so work in and around Canary Wharf, currently around 7,000 have returned to work in the development. Businesses that rely on these consumers, coffee shops, restaurants, pubs, bars etc have all seen a sharp decline in takings but they still have to pay rent and with little or no income they face a very stark reality – one that is being played out up and down the country.
This is all set against a backdrop of economic uncertainty, which when you consider we are already in the depths of the most serious recession on record, and the steepest decline in our economy since records began, we can ill afford to witness, which is why in my view a National Time Out needs to be negotiate as a priority.
- Jamie is the owner of Rothay Manor Luxury Hotel and Fine Dining in the Heart of the Lake District



