Covid Rent Arrears: More Decisions

Christopher Clayton, Solicitor -Advocate Baines Wilson LLP

There have been a series of key decisions over the issue of Commercial rent arrears accrued during the Covid-19 pandemic says Christopher Clayton of Baines Wilson LLP.

Last month we published an article on a series of arbitration awards under the new statutory arbitration scheme – see here.

On the back of those decisions, we now have two more key decisions this time arising from the Courts rather than arbitration.  Both cases saw tenants deploy legally complex and innovative arguments in order to circumvent liability for rent arrears when the tenant’s businesses were the subject of forced closure measures beyond their control.

Bank of New York Mellon (International) Ltd v C-UK Limited & Others [2021] EWHC 1013 (QB)

In this case, the Landlord was bringing a claim against various Tenants for non-payment of rent.  The Tenants argued that they had been unable to trade during the periods of lockdown which had adversely impacted their ability to pay rent.  Further, in this case, the Landlord actually managed to obtain pandemic insurance which included loss of rent regardless as to whether or not the property was damaged or destroyed, whereas the lease included a provision for suspension of rent where the property was damaged or destroyed.

The grounds upon which the Tenants relied to avoid paying rent were as follows:-

  • Summary judgment was unsuitable for claims involving technically complex defences.
  • We draw your attention to the voluntary Code of Practice which encouraged Landlords to negotiate with Tenants regarding unpaid rent where Tenants’ businesses were affected by Covid-19.
  • Existing clauses in the Lease regarding rent suspension should be construed to cover Covid pandemic enforced closures and that words such as “damage or destruction” should include inability to trade.
  • Terms reflecting paragraph iii above should be implied into the Lease.
  • The Landlord procured pandemic insurance, which the Tenants paid for, covering the non-payment of rent, therefore the Tenants should be entitled to not pay rent.
  • The effect of the lockdown emergency regulations frustrated the contract.

The most interesting aspects of the judgment were points (iv), (v) and (vi).  The Court considered that the lockdown was not unforeseeable and made reference to the SARS pandemic 20 years ago.  The Court said it was as a result of the SARS pandemic that Landlords tend to obtain pandemic related insurance and said it was up to the Tenants to obtain similar insurance.  Landlords are concerned to insure their buildings, but similarly it is for the Tenant to insure what it feels is important, for example business interruption for which insurance is available.

The Courts determined that damage to the property was irrelevant in relation to the cause of the suspended rent because the property was not damaged or destroyed. For the purposes of the lease, the rent had not been “lost” and was therefore due and payable.

The judgment found, most crucially, that the contract was not frustrated as a result of the pandemic.  Frustration of contract arises where it is impossible for the contract to be performed as envisaged.  While the pandemic lockdown regulations were certainly unprecedented and could, in principle, qualify as a supervening event, the forced closures could not reasonably have been expected to last for much more than 18 months.  The Leases in this case had at least one more year to run from the point of the Court hearing when the 1954 Act protection was taken into account.  In the context of the lease as a whole, the closures were relatively minor and the Court was satisfied, on that basis, the Leases were not frustrated.

London Trocadero (2015) LLP v Picture House Cinemas Limited [2021] EWHC 2591 (CH)

This case saw the Tenant seeking to argue, somewhat ingeniously, that the permitted user clause of the Lease meant that, when the Tenant’s business was forced to close, there was a total failure of consideration – also known as a failure of basis – because the Tenant was not able to use the building in accordance with the permitted user clause.

The permitted user clause stated that the Tenant could only use the building as a cinema and the Landlord did not warrant that the property could be lawfully used as such.

During the pandemic, the emergency regulations imposed required cinemas to close for a specified period.  During those periods, Cinemas could not trade at all and in the gaps between restrictions, trade was so poor that the cinema remained close in any event.  When the cinema was open, takings were severely impacted in any event.

The Tenant’s had not paid any rent at all since June 2020.  As a result, the Landlord issued proceedings for non-payment of rent and sought summary judgement in respect of all arrears of rent and service charges totalling £2.9million.

The Tenant argued that a term suspending rent payments during periods of forced closure should be implied into the Lease.  Secondly, the Tenant argued that the rent payments were in respect of use of the building as a cinema and, because the Tenant could not use the building as a cinema, that amounted to a total failure of consideration.

The Judge rejected the Tenant’s claim on both grounds.  In respect of implied terms, the Judge considered whether it was necessary to imply a term into the contract in order to give it business efficacy and whether the term was so obvious that it goes without saying and it should form part of the contract.  The answer to both of those questions was no, and so the Judge rejected the Tenant’s assertion that a rent suspension should be implied into the contract.

Further, to imply such a term would have contradicted certain express terms of the Lease.  There were express provisions within the Lease regarding rent suspensions, for example if the building could not be used as a result of an insured damage, which indicated that the risk of not being able to use the building as a result of circumstances other than those set out in the Lease lay with the Tenant.

The Court rejected the contention that there was a total failure of consideration on the grounds that the use of the building as a cinema “was not fundamental to the basis” on which the parties entered into the Lease.  The permitted user clause was an expectation which motivated the parties to enter the Lease, in the Court’s view, and not a reason to find that the Landlord had completely failed in its obligations to the Tenant under the Lease.

Comments

As expected, these two decisions both found that the rents remain due and payable despite the forced closure requirements introduced as a result of the pandemic.  At its most basic level, a lease is a contract and, even though various other measures were open to the Landlords (such as forfeiture etc.) were temporarily suspended, there was never any suggestion that commercial rents were temporarily suspended.  All of the measures introduced by the Government encouraged Landlords and Tenants to speak to each other regarding difficulties paying rent, however, it was always clear that the rent remained payable.

This is good news for commercial Landlords because, in view of these decisions, it will be exceptionally difficult for a Tenant to successfully persuade a Court that it should not have to pay its rent.  It should be noted, however, that the decisions in the London Trocadero case is likely to be appealed.

It is not such good news for Tenants who will no doubt feel aggrieved because their businesses were forced to be closed for reasons beyond their control.  In accordance with our previous article, Tenants still have sufficient time to refer a matter for arbitration, which probably represents a better chance of securing a more favourable deal than seeking to defend any actions in the Courts brought by their Landlords.

If you are a Landlord or a Tenant experiencing disputes regarding commercial rent arrears, get in touch with our dispute resolution team who will be able to advise you as to your options with a view to finding a resolution on the best possible terms.

Leave a Reply

*

I accept the Privacy Policy