Insurers couldn’t cover themselves against discrimination claims

Caroline Rayner of Baines Wilson LLP

In this week’s alert, we look at a recent tribunal case where an insurance company faced a number of claims including discrimination, harassment and unfair dismissal brought by one of its underwriters says Caroline Rayner of Baines Wilson LLP.

Sommer v Swiss Re Corporate Solutions Services Ltd 

Ms Sommer worked for insurance company Swiss Re Corporate Solutions Services Ltd as a Political Risk Underwriter from June 2017 until she was made redundant shortly after returning from maternity leave. During the course of her employment, Ms Sommer found the behaviour of the head of the global underwriting department, Mr Llewellyn, had crossed the line on numerous occasions.

Ms Sommer evidenced this through referring to various incidents.  These included attending a “work drinks” event with Mr Llewellyn in 2017 at which she joked to a group of people that she was going to demand that her boyfriend married her.  She alleged that Mr Llewellyn responded by saying ‘if I had breasts like yours, I’d be demanding too’, which he subsequently followed up with ‘I bet you like being on top in bed’. Witnesses reported that Ms Sommer discussed her relationship at social drinks which could have been perceived as unprofessional.  This open culture was encouraged by management.  She also took exception to Mr Llewelyn calling her “hun” which she found condescending and said he did not address male peers with such familiarity and intimacy.

Ms Sommer cited various other comments made by Mr Llewellyn throughout her employment, including comments he made during a meeting at which he encouraged her to take a ‘more submissive role’ when discussing her career progression, to ‘show more vulnerability’ and to speak less and listen more. There were some concerns around Ms Sommer’s personality such as her being too loud and opinionated, and during one meeting Mr Llewelyn interrupted her during a team call and told her to “shut up” – he said she talked over people and would have reacted the same way to a man. She said she felt disrespected and undermined.

By April 2019, Mr Llewellyn had decided that Ms Sommer would be managed out of the business.  360-degree feedback and personality tests were directed at Ms Sommer designed to make her either accept she didn’t have a future there and leave, or they would start a capability process.  These were not standard processes and others did not have to do them.

At the end of April 2019, Ms Sommer informed management that she was pregnant. Due to to issues around her health during her pregnancy, she made a request to work from home to help her manage this however her request was denied.  Swiss pushed on with the 360-degree feedback and personality tests with Ms Sommer.  There was a lot of negative feedback about her but also some positive.

She started her maternity leave in September 2019 and said she wanted to have a year off. No card or present was given to her at that time or on the birth of her child which was done for others taking maternity or paternity leave.  Before her return, Mr Llewelyn said that the next steps would be either a performance improvement plan or redundancy.  Upon her return, Ms Sommer said that team meetings were arranged on the days that she was off and would not be rearranged, Mr Llewelyn denied her requests to discuss ongoing deals and unfairly criticised her, and she felt ostracised.

Ms Sommer was put at risk of redundancy shortly after returning from maternity leave.  She challenged this and found that no one else in the team had been put at risk, no one else was in a selection pool with her and there was no scoring.  However Swiss said this was legitimate.  She raised a grievance and alleged that her selection amounted to maternity, race and sex discrimination.

Ms Sommer brought claims in the employment tribunal including sex discrimination, pregnancy and maternity discrimination, sexual harassment, equal pay, victimisation and unfair dismissal.

Decision

Ms Sommer was successful in part in her sex discrimination claims.  For example, the tribunal found that using the 360-degree feedback and personality tests to attempt to achieve her exit by targeting her personality, and comments made at the work drinks and the meetings where she was told to shut up, and to be more vulnerable etc. amounted to direct sex discrimination and sex harassment.

The tribunal found that from February 2019 until her dismissal, it was decided that Ms Sommer should be exited from the business after Mr Llewelyn failed to control his temper during a team call.  Advice was taken from HR to terminate her employment on different grounds such as performance and then redundancy.  The tribunal found the business case for redundancy implausible.  At the time, Mr Llewelyn was still considering whether to implement a performance improvement plan, and he decided that it was more convenient to tag her dismissal as redundancy however there was not a true redundancy situation.  There was no evidence of a reduction in the work for underwriters, or a reorganisation that lessened the need for a junior underwriter. The decision to dismiss had already been made.  This amounted to a continuing act of sex discrimination throughout that time, as did organising meetings on her days off and refusing to reorganise them, ignoring her and unfairly criticising her.    Placing her at risk of redundancy was also an act of direct sex discrimination.

She was successful in part in her pregnancy and maternity discrimination claims which included the refusal of her request to work from home after announcing her pregnancy and being asked to make herself available for a handover call when she was off sick.  The refusal to allow her to work from home was part of the strategy for exiting her from the business. Failing to inform Ms Sommer of vacancies during her maternity leave was also maternity-related discrimination.

The tribunal also found that the use of redundancy was “retrofitted” onto a pre-existing decision to exit Ms Sommer and as such was an unfair dismissal.

Her equal pay and victimisation claims were dismissed.  The amounts awarded will be dealt with separately at a remedy hearing.

Comment

In this case, the discrimination claims brought by Ms Sommer related mainly to the comments and actions of one individual and is another reminder that employers are vicariously liable for the acts of their employees, even where the acts are done without the employer’s knowledge.  This can be avoided where employers can show that they have taken all reasonable steps to prevent this from happening in the first place, such as having up to date and properly implemented policies and training which is regularly refreshed.

It is also a stark reminder to employers not to “dress up” issues relating to performance, conduct or other issues such as personality clashes as redundancy, and to deal with such issues head on, following a procedure which is appropriate to the circumstances.  One of the first things that the tribunal will look at is whether there is a genuine redundancy situation, and the employer needs to be able to demonstrate a sound business reason for this.  Employers should also take care to involve employees who are on maternity leave in team updates and maintain appropriate contact, and to exercise caution when managing requests made by pregnant employees such as in this case.

If you have any questions in relation to discrimination, redundancy or any other HR queries, please contact our employment team on 01228 552600 or 01524 548494.

Leave a Reply

*

I accept the Privacy Policy